ESSENTIAL READING · PAPER 41

Can we trust LLMs as a tutor for our students? Evaluating the Quality of LLM-generated Feedback in Statistics Exams

Herklotz, M., Ippisch, N., & Haensch, A.-C. (2025). Can we trust LLMs as a tutor for our students? Evaluating the Quality of LLM-generated Feedback in Statistics Exams. arXiv preprint arXiv:2511.04213.

FOUND

At a Munich university statistics course, about 7% of AI feedback contained errors — and lacked depth.

MEANS

AI feedback needs quality monitoring in the loop; it cannot be left unsupervised.

SI DATA

No direct SI dataset counterpart yet — flagged for future audit expansion.